The Exorcism of Emily Rose has a clever idea: put an exorcism on trial. Instead of starting with the horror, it starts after Emily is already dead, and asks a jury to decide what really happened to her. The story then moves between the courtroom and flashbacks of her terrifying final months.
The flashbacks are where the film shines. Jennifer Carpenter gives a fearless performance, bending her body and twisting her voice in ways that look painful and real, with very little help from effects. Her first attack in a college dorm at 3 a.m. and the exorcism in a stormy farmhouse are among the most memorable possession scenes of their decade.
Laura Linney and Tom Wilkinson are excellent as a skeptical lawyer and a gentle, sincere priest. The film is fair to both sides, letting doctors argue for epilepsy and psychosis while the priest argues for demons, and it leaves much for you to decide.
The courtroom half is more talk than terror, and some viewers will wish for more scares. The film also leans toward the religious side by the end. But as a thoughtful, sad and genuinely creepy possession movie, it is well worth watching.







