This is horror with the hope taken out. Bertino is not interested in a clever twist or a neat set of rules. He wants you to feel the same helpless dread as Louise and Michael, and he succeeds.
Marin Ireland is excellent as Louise, a daughter full of guilt for staying away too long. Michael Abbott Jr. gives Michael a quiet, worn-out sadness. Their grief feels real, which makes the horror hit harder when the entity starts to use it against them.
The craft is outstanding. The camera lingers on empty doorways and dark fields, the sound design makes every creak feel dangerous, and the jump scares are some of the best of the decade. Critics like Matt Zoller Seitz compared its creeping dread to classics such as Don't Look Now.
It is not for everyone. The story is thin, the evil is never explained, and the film is so bleak that some viewers find it exhausting. IndieWire called it a collection of chilling images with paper-thin logic. But if you want to be truly scared, few recent films do it better.











